Frequently Asked Questions
The following are questions I have received from e-mail submissions and from inquiries during my windmill presentations. If you would like to submit a question, just send an e-mail and I will answer it thoroughly and promptly.
I am amazed at the windmills near Paw Paw, IL. Why are there so many in just that one area, and what is their purpose?
Paw Paw is one of a few towns that is home to the first wind farm installed in Illinois, known as Mendota Hills. As part of his power conservation plan, former Governor Rod Blagojevich worked to add renewable energy plants to the state’s power grid.
This site was chosen particularly because of the prevailing westerly winds and completely open plains. A wind farm like this couldn’t possibly work in the city or suburbs because there are too many obstructions.
Why did they build a windmill in Mount Emblem Cemetery?
Many people assume that the cemetery was established first; but the land was first owned by Henry Fischer, who operated a farm and built the windmill in 1865-67. The mill was later sold to Edward Ehlers.
In 1925, the land was sold to the Mount Emblem Cemetery Association, which chose to preserve the windmill and transform the flat farmland into the hilly tree-lined cemetery we see today. To the right is a photo of the mill and farm with a billboard announcing the cemetery would be coming soon.
Why was Batavia the center for wind engine manufacturing?
Batavia was home to Halladay’s U.S. Wind Engine and Pump Company, the first windmill manufacturer in the nation. It made the most business sense for Halladay to set up shop in Batavia because of its proximity to railroads (to ship windmills and parts anywhere in the nation) and because it was nestled in the vast corn fields of Illinois (since the clients were farmers and railroad owners).
The ever-flowing Fox River also provided plenty of water for the operation, which included steam-powered saws and tools for creating the metal-and-wood engines.
After U.S. Wind Engine started, the Challenge and Appleton engine companies moved in, and so began some of the most competitive marketing and sales campaigns prior to the twentieth century.
Why is the platform called a stage?
The term “stage” is accurate because it is a platform from which an action is performed by a person (as opposed to a terrace or balcony, which is used for leisure or relaxing), and is the traditional term used by millwrights.
Why are the windmills in Illinois called “Dutch”?
Even though the windmills in Illinois are mixed with German, Swedish, Danish, British, Flemish, American, and Dutch architecture, they are still often incorrectly referred to as "Dutch" mills.
Realistically speaking, they all appear very similar to the style of windmill that was perfected and popularized by the Dutch. The historical records kept during the nineteenth century were often inaccurate or incomplete.
What is the difference between German and Dutch mills?
There are a few differences. Really, a mill and its style are based on its builder’s preferences and background. The Dutch developed the smock mill as we know it, but the Germans modernized the style.
German mills are usually wider at the base to accommodate more machinery, have shingled exteriors (as opposed to the Dutch, who used reed thatch), and more often have tail fans to rotate the cap rather than a winch.
Other minor differences may include the way in which the floor joists are cut and mortised into the cant posts. The styles are all generally similar, especially since the countries neighbor one another.
How many [custom] windmills are in Illinois?
There are five custom windmills in Illinois.
When commenting on the condition of the Graue Mill (a restored water mill in DuPage County), Leslie C. Swanson, author of Old Mills in the Midwest, wrote “1,800 old mills...once dotted the Illinois landscape.”
I do not know how many of those 1,800 mills could have been windmills. Even in frontier Illinois, wind-powered mills were scarce because of their unreliability. To date, I am aware of fifty windmills that used to stand in this state.
Were there ever any windmills in Chicago?
Yes, there were at least four that I am aware of:
At 111th and State in the Roseland community.
At the present site of the Carl Schurz High School in Old Irving Park
At Lincoln Park, back when land owned by Samuel McKay was purchased for the old Chicago Cemetery in the 1850s.
Near the “reservation tract” in 1839.
Why are Dutch windmills made of wood?
For one, landowners in Holland would often relocate windmills on their property in an attempt to find the best location to catch the wind, thus realizing their mills’ maximum potential.
Another other reason is that wood is one of the cheapest building materials. Since windmills often fall victim to high winds in severe weather, their broken parts can replaced as often as needed at a low cost.
Yet another reason is that the very fine dust produced by grinding flour is flammable. If metal parts within the mill were to spark (even if just from normal vibration), it could ignite the dust and cause an explosion.
Why are so few windmills equipped with tail fans?
The tail fan, invented in Britain by Edmund Lee in 1745, is used to automatically wind the cap without any action by the miller.
While this was seen as a great convenience to some millers, the tail fan was never a popular design feature in Holland, where millers preferred to have manual control over the direction of the sails. One reason, they claimed, was that the tail fan would turn the sails into the wind of a powerful storm.
Why do windmills with tail fans sometimes still have tie beams in the cap?
As I experienced first-hand with my model windmill project, the extra timbers at the rear of the cap help to counter-balance the weight of the sails and wind shaft; without them, it could be easier for the wind to blow the cap off of the tower in a tail wind.
Another answer, however, is that the mill may have, at one time, been operating with a tail pole prior to the installation of the tail fan.
Where can I go to see if our farm can be considered to be leased for a wind farm?
You would first need to contact one of the major power companies in your area (be it ComEd, or whomever); or, better yet, contact one of the companies that produces wind turbines (such as Vestas). That would probably be the better route, since an outside company would be making the major investment involved in construction a wind farm.
I would assume that they would want to first conduct a wind analysis to see if your area is windy enough to constitute constructing a wind farm. After that, they'd just have to secure funding, order the turbines, and up they'd go!
What is the best resource for information about wind turbines?
The American Wind Energy Association, or AWEA, has just about everything anyone would want to know about wind turbines, including current and future projects, fact sheets, and wind data for every state. Find them at www.awea.org.
What happened to the McKee painting of the Fischer Windmill?
The painting was donated by the eighth grade graduating class of 1952 from Oak Avenue School in LaGrange Park, Illinois to the Nettie J. McKinnon Collection of American Art, which is managed by the Salt Creek American Art Foundation.
The painting itself was originally made in 1949 after John Dukes McKee was commissioned to paint 50 Northern Illinois landmarks (including the windmill) by the Illinois Northern Utilities Company.
I was wondering if you know any good colleges that teach windmill tech in Illinois?
There are wind-tech classes through the Department of Technology at Illinois State University in Normal, IL. You can find a list of links to schools in this field from the U.S. Department of Energy website.
Why aren’t there more turbines in the suburbs?
Although a number of residents in outlying areas (like Joliet and Plainfield) have erected turbines for their homes, larger turbines (like Big Windy in Schiller Park, pictured to the right) have been requested but are often met with opposition.
In addition to the red tape required to have a large-scale turbine built, the suburbs are more densely populated and may block the wind necessary to make such a turbine successful.
That being said, former Governor Pat Quinn signed the School District Intergovernmental Cooperation Renewable Energy Act, allowing schools to use solar and wind energy to power their facilities.
How come a few wind turbines will not turn, even on windy days?
Wind turbines must undergo maintenance tune-ups every thirty days. Thus, on a 150-turbine wind farm, it should not be uncommon to see 5 different wind turbines down every day for maintenance (after all - it would not be economical to shut down all 150 units for a single day of maintenance).
Turbines may also be decommissioned if weather conditions are too severe, too light, or if mechanical problems are detected that could prevent safe operation.